Are We at or Near the Tipping Point?

Quote

Prima facie, a four-order magnitude difference in pits from D2O runs versus one from H2O runs sounds robust; do you agree?

Not without checking! Would you like me to check just one of these papers first, or go through them in chronological order?

Quote from Thomas Clarke

Not without checking! Would you like me to check just one of these papers first, or go through them in chronological order?

I think we agree about this -- it's why I used the phrase "prima facie."

Since neither you nor I are an expert in this particular subject matter, I would like you to put together a criticism and submit it to that journal for peer review. Otherwise my opinion will be just as good as your opinion. If the errors are basic, your job should be straightforward.

This should not be as daunting as it might at first sound. Ludwik Kowalski (I believe he's the same one I'm familiar with), who also published a criticism, has a background in mathematics.