Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion

  • You're a natural!


    Not one single person

    on this planet earth

    has ever seen a working E-whatever

    no building or robot, no production line

    no building inspector, no delivery truck driver, lame,

    No employee, no OSHA inspector,

    no peer review, no external source of data

    no trusted anything anywhere by anyone

    not ever, you Rossi lover


  • That might be the non zero constant of integration, which PfD omitted. Also, it is questionable that the function was continuous to begin with. Nevertheless he gets a thumbs up for creativity.

    Time (in units of years) is a continuous variable. Plus constants of integration only apply to indefinite integrals. Did you develop Rossi's hexadecimal Clifford algebra?

  • *If* I had an invention I knew worked, and if I knew I could significantly improve it with some more time, and if I wanted to leave any competition in the dust and dominate the market for the foreseeable future, almost surely I would delay a mass market release. Rossi is doing what I would do.


    But Rossi is 70 years old. I'd sell the rights and buy a few luxury condos somewhere warm and sunny to live out my remaining days playing tennis with my wife.

  • It's almost unfathomable that such alleged activity and progress could be made in a mere decade isn't it.

    Very poetic


    That might be the non zero constant of integration, which PfD omitted. Also, it is questionable that the function was continuous to begin with. Nevertheless he gets a thumbs up for creativity.


    Just a small correction. PFD has pointed out there can be no constant of integration here.


    In addition, not only was his function (by inspection) continuous, but in fact integration is well defined for discontinuous functions. All that is required is they be measurable.


    On second thoughts that perhaps is an issue here. Rossi usually presents systems which are impossible to measure, or, when possible to measure, he measures them wrong.


  • Sam,

    Rossi posted over and over again that the Doral customer was a independent entity, with their own staff and using the eCat in production. That the ERV (expert responsible for validation, a Rossi term) was independent and doing all the measurements with their own equipment.


    It was all a proven lie via court documents. There was no customer, there was no production. The "ERV" was Rossi's long time friend and DID NOT take the measurements or use his own equipment. Rossi emailed him the "readings"... some of which were proved impossible.


    Rossi has made these very same claims you list above on EVERY VERSION of the eCat since 2011. That is a decade! Not once has it been true! WHY DO YOU BELIEVE HIM NOW?

  • Because it is too frustrating to admit that the Skeptics have always been right :D


    Heck, the Rossi skeptics probably are right! No problem admitting this. What I won't admit (now) is that Rossi skeptics are certainly right, and that Rossi has nothing that works. Why do some like myself believe Rossi now, despite no lasting evidence of a real device? Rossi surely realizes that this belief of his fans, while sincere, is tentative, not absolute. He will have to face the music, and I very much hope that is the music of celebration rather than one of Neil Sedaka's songs about something that is hard to do.

  • Heck, the Rossi skeptics probably are right! No problem admitting this. What I won't admit (now) is that Rossi skeptics are certainly right, and that Rossi has nothing that works. Why do some like myself believe Rossi now, despite no lasting evidence of a real device? Rossi surely realizes that this belief of his fans, while sincere, is tentative, not absolute. He will have to face the music, and I very much hope that is the music of celebration rather than one of Neil Sedaka's songs about something that is hard to do.


    Mark,

    The main fault with your above logic is that Rossi never has to "face the music". He simply gets another fan base! Some of us here have seen literally dozens of believers come and go. You and Sam12 are relative new comers, you have simply taken the place of many before you. Rossi does not have to face the music as he (and Frank Ackland) simply block / ban anyone who questions them. Do not believe me? Start posting some realistic hard questions on ECW and see how long you last!


    So no, Rossi does not have to be worried about his fan base... he hand picks them via banning and only the faithful can remain. Just like all cults do..... and the only time a cult leader faces the music, is when an outside entity (normally a law enforcement department) jails them due to money fraud (or other abhorrent abuse.)


    So I believe your particular logic on this is quite faulty. Another reason people ask why he would continue for so long..... $10 million reasons.... and he is hoping to cash in on more! Remember, internet demos from your condo kitchen (or was it living room) does not require any investment and is well worth the possible reward! Please explain why Rossi put more money into his puppets than the did his reactor in the last demo! A blue box, with a big RED button!