Dear all, I do enjoy these calcs. But not the company!
In a peer review, even those doing the review don't get a pass! Part of the process. But you are doing a great job explaining yourself, and the dynamics involved, so please keep it up. Tough I know being a skeptic at LENR central, but someone has to do it.
That said, I think the Mizuno side is winning this debate quite handily. Not that I am biased, but even to my untrained eye, it looks like M and R built a tight calorimeter, and accounted for all the input vs output.
So far they have provided the superior answers to the probing questions. I have yet to see any weakness/error in their defense.
I don't say that to discourage, but to encourage more poking around. Important this thing pass the most rigorous examination, before ICCF.