You seem to have a good grasp about current subjects, however how do you explain that an eminent replicator as magicsound can't reproduce Mizuno's announced breakthrough ?
I have no earthly idea. You would have to one of them visit and spend a month in the lab working hands-on to find out. Maybe it would take six months. Or a year. Or never. That is the nature of scientific research. You are dealing with the unknown. You are doing things that no one in human history has done. It is like being the first person to cross the Bering straits to enter North America. You cannot possibly know what is ahead. I am no expert, but even if I were John Bockris reincarnated I could not possibly say why this replication is not working (so far) without going there and looking at the physical evidence. You cannot understand an experiment by speculation.
Sometimes, if you are very skilled, experienced and lucky, you can replicate from a description. Sometimes you can replicate with help. It seems Dr. Saito in Japan has replicated, mainly with equipment and advice from Mizuno. I do not know how independent it is. I only know that Saito's calorimetry is better than Mizuno's. Roughly a hundred professional electrochemists were able to replicate Fleischmann and Pons in 1989 and 1990. It took them between 3 months and year, depending mainly on the palladium. Either they got lucky, or Uncle Martin gave them a sample of the Johnson Matthey palladium he recommended. Those people had been doing electrochemistry for decades. If they hadn't, they would not have succeeded. Richard Oriani told me that in his 50 year career, this was the most difficult experiment he ever did.