COVID-19 Vaccine Damage Bill – British Politician Proposes COVID Vaccine Compensation
Despite growing uneasiness around the globe surrounding reports of adverse effects from COVID-19 vaccinations, TrialSite has found that few governments take decisive action in response to such concerns. In the UK, Sir Christopher Chope MP, Conservative, proposed the COVID-19 Vaccine Damage Bill for its second reading in the House of Commons on September 10, 2021. The measure would oblige the government to conduct an unbiased investigation into “disablement caused by COVID-19 vaccinations” and whether those who have reported serious side effects from the vaccine can access adequate compensation. He emphasized the necessity for transparency when publishing severe side effects.
Side effects are self-reported via the ‘yellow-card’ system
Previously, TrialSite reported on the UK Yellow Card System which allows the public to report potential side effects from coronavirus testing, treatment, medications, vaccinations, medical devices, and test kits. The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) will get the report.
On September 10, Sir Christopher Chope MP presented information extracted from the Yellow Card Scheme reports. “There have been 435 reports of major blood clots and low platelet counts, including 74 deaths. It shows that there have been 767 cases of inflammation of the heart, a condition that is almost unheard of in medicine on a normal day-to-day basis. It shows that there have been some 35,000 reports of menstrual disorder, and there are all sorts of other effects set out in the comprehensive report. Very worryingly, it says that there are 1,632 reports of deaths that have taken place shortly after vaccination.”
The MHRA records reports of possible adverse drug reactions (ADRs) in the UK in cases where a patient dies soon after receiving a COVID-19 vaccine. As of the date of the second reading of the bill, these figures were:
524 reports related to Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine
1,064 reports related to the AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine
16 reports for the COVID-19 vaccine from Moderna
28 reports with no brand name specified
The bulk of these cases included elderly people or those who had underlying medical conditions.
However, the MHRA states that Yellow Card data cannot be used to calculate side effect rates or compare the safety profile of COVID-19 vaccines because a variety of factors can affect ADR reporting.
Data on deaths after vaccination as yet unreported
In the second reading of the Vaccine Damage Bill, Sir Christopher Chope told the Secretary of the State that if they want to increase vaccine confidence, they must be transparent about the adverse effects of vaccines with the public. The public must have the ability to inform themselves with official, factual publications regarding potential damages caused by vaccines rather than rely on self-reported data.
He stated that COVID-19 vaccines are causing far more harm to UK civilians than any previous vaccination program in history. “What is crucial is that if individuals do the right thing, they should not be denied access to compensation,” he added.
He inquired about the number of deaths reported in patients who have died since January 1, within (a) one month, (b) two months, and (c) three months of receiving a COVID-19 vaccination.
The response he got was “Data on the number of deaths reported of people who have died within one, two, and three months of having received a COVID-19 vaccination since 1 January 2021 is not available in the format requested.”
Public Health England (PHE) monitors the number of people who have been admitted to the hospital and died from COVID-19 despite receiving one or two doses of the vaccine, but the data has not been published yet. An observational study by the same body finds Pfizer-BioNTech and AstraZeneca vaccines are effective against Indian and UK COVID-19 variants.
A notable precedent: The Vaccine Damage Payments Scheme
If a UK resident incurs injury as a result of receiving a COVID-19 vaccine, they may be eligible for financial assistance through the Vaccine Damage Payments Scheme (VDPS).
The Pearson Commission introduced the Vaccine Damage Payments Act in 1979 with regard to compensation for injury sustained as a result of vaccines. However, Sir Christopher Chope MP stated that “the Act makes provision of a maximum payment of £120,000 together with a threshold of 60% disablement. As a result, fewer than 2% of applications are successful.”
Sir Christopher Chope MP emphasized that immediate action is required to provide confidence to those who are already suffering. He stated that “Our hospitals have a large number of in-patients who are there only because they took the vaccine. It is causing a lot of angst for consultants across the country.”
During his speech, he did not disclose the sources he alluded to while making his allegations. In June 2021, the total number of occupied bed days, which is a measure of bed availability in a month, was 84% compared to 89% in December 2020, when the COVID-19 vaccination program started. However, none of the figures specify the number of vaccinated vs. unvaccinated persons.
Does this bill have a future?
The bill is not backed by a political party, and history shows this type of bill is unlikely to succeed to the extent that it is enacted in law. The debate around it, however, can prove an important testing ground, and a foundation for future bills and legislation.
The ideal approach, according to Sir Christopher Chope MP, would be to implement a no-fault compensation plan, which would eliminate the need for victims to establish fault and would automatically qualify them for compensation. This is similar to an agreement signed on February 17, 2021 between the World Health Organization (WHO) and Chubb Limited, in which the COVAX program aims to reduce the need for resort to the law courts, which can be a lengthy and costly process, by providing a no-fault lump sum compensation in full and final settlement of any claims. The bill’s next stage, the second reading, is scheduled for Friday, October 22, 2021.