Jed challenged me to find fault with 3 electrolysis experiments with better calorimetry than F&P and positive results.
I will make it easier for Jed. he can post his best 3 electrolysis excess heat experiments of all time. At least I think that is easier - of course if Jed reckons there are less than three such better than F&P experiments he has set me an impossible challenge.
Given 3 electrolysis GOATs - I promise on this thread to look at them and for each one:
1. Admit there is no critique I can find that could invalidate the results
2. Provide in detail such a critique, and how the experiment could be tightened up to avoid it.
Any one such that stands up to this, from a researcher everyone here trusts, should be a candidate for replication given that we have now (I think?) cracked how to obtain and condition electrode that will work.
PS - this is a separate thread because if Jed posts his answers on another thread they will get lost in noise and when I have time (probably start of July) to come back to them with some serious checking - which takes time - I will have lots them.
This is a challenge I do not want to shirk.