@candide89: The weak point of your argumentation is point 5
QuoteMr Parkhomov, Songshen Jiang et al [...] and build a replica eCat.
In both experiements, by Parkhomov and Songshen, there are big questionmarks and odd behaviours. Therefore the whole experiments are highly questionable.
We can not be sure to date.
I simply hope that MFMP found the key (the recipe) and that more transparent and positive experiments are coming soon.