Where did you get 5 X the rubber? I don't see that anywhere. It uses more rubber, but not 5 times more.
That was my bad. Up to twice as much rubber.
Among my many weird adventures, I came into a considerable number of heavily used, kids-type, electric “ATVs”. Working in an electrical shop of sorts these were always coming to get repaired, but only a few were worth sinking any money into. Sometimes the customers never came back after calling to see what it might cost. The rest we recycled what we could, scavenged the parts that could be used and eventually there was a decent inventory on tiny electric kids ATVs.
So naturally, me and a coworker decided to soup one up. (Customers frequently asked if this was something we could do). Many customers had actually tried to soup these up, so we were aware of the few primary problems.The tires are plastic and don’t have traction, so they spin a start-off. Adding more voltage (battery changes) just spins out the tires even more. Adding rubber to the tires and more power then shears the gears off the electric motors or transmission because they aren’t strong enough.
Lowering the voltage on a rubber enhanced ATV toy to a almost happy spot made the thing rattle and Ike crazy as the tires gripped and the transmission climbed the gears until It could force the tire to move in a erratic rhythm. And that is just in a straight line. Eventually the gears fail. The slidy plastic tires were the engineers solution to preventing the destruction of the drivetrain of the toy. The toys, as received, are durable, but fail rapidly when modified.
(Slippery tires are probably not the solution for electric cars, but who knows? Custom engineered Non-Newtonian tire rubber, anyone?)
So anyways, electric cars can control that a lot better with traction control and tons of electronics. There should be no long term reason the tires should wear out faster. I know some OEM tires are not the same spec as the replacements with the same numbers. They are often lighter for better reported model mileage, and some OEM new tires are often quieter, particularly on light trucks.