Ascoli65 Member

  • from Italy
  • Member since May 28th 2016
  • Last Activity:
Posts
755
Likes Received
327
Points
4,102
Profile Hits
1,354
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread 3000th LENR-Forum Member!.
    Post
    (Quote from Alan Smith)


    As insistently asked by Rothwell (1), I looked at the F&P documents and found serious errors which invalidate both the conclusions of their major paper. I illustrated these errors to the LENR community without receiving any…
  • Ascoli65

    Like (Post)
    (Quote)

    "broad" is a weasel-word but aside from that, if the evidence pointed to a likelihood of a new source of plentiful and cheap energy, entrepreneurs would be all over it like... well, you know.
  • Ascoli65

    Like (Post)
    (Quote)

    It is? Ask the typical nuclear physicist about it. Or nuclear engineer.
    Oh, I forgot. Most scientists and engineers are either dismally ignorant or, shudder, skeptopaths.
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread 3000th LENR-Forum Member!.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)


    Rossi took inspiration from F&P. His ongoing story is just the natural continuation of that of F&P. IMO, you avoid rehashing F&P because you have no argument to rebut the criticisms on their claims.

    Sorry to say, Shane, but by…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread 3000th LENR-Forum Member!.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)


    Thanks to Rossi and the Ecat!

    Right now there are 3 threads which are going full steam ahead on these 2 topics, rehashing the same old arguments (the Doral test, the Prominent pump, … the mezzanine!) already debated in thousands…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from AlainCo)


    I cited Wilson and Morrison just to respond to JR, who asked: "If Ascoli65 has some authorities in mind who have published arguments and facts that call into question these experiments, he should tell us who they are."

    I don't use…
  • Ascoli65

    Post
    (Quote from JedRothwell)


    Morrison and Wilson have published some valid arguments against the validity of the F&P experiments. In particular, Morrison has raised many remarks on the 1992 boil-off experiment. Some of them were valid, but he failed in…
  • Ascoli65

    Post
    (Quote from JedRothwell)


    Cold fusion has already demonstrated that "power density equivalent to a nuclear fission reactor core" can be claimed on the basis of misrepresented data:

  • CF/LENR strategy

    Defy
    Notes:
    - Quotations from JR posts in this thread "How many times has the PF AHE event been replicated"
    - Quoted paragraphs are reported integrally
    - Highlights (bold & color) added

    How many times has the
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from Paradigmnoia)


    That is foamy-true!
    As was inspired by F&P in 1996, he says.
    Which science-ward do you expect to move?
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from RobertBryant)


    Thank you for translation.
    I've problem with English, but even more with LENRish!

    But please stop commenting on my posts, otherwise the adms/mods will be tempted to reopen the F&P thread for "a resurrection of interest",…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from oystla)


    This is true only for your criticisms. I didn't mention them because they were an exceptions. Anyway, yes, most of your criticisms were very factual, even if, IMO, they were wrong, as I tried to explain in my replies. But don't…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from Wyttenbach)


    Either I am having serious problems with English, or you have big serious problems with logic.

    (Quote from Alan Smith)


    My answer was just relative to me, because I was answering a question which was relative to me.

    Hmm. But at…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from Alan Smith)


    Absolutely not. It was not my intent to misrepresent the opinion of other members. Let me clarify this point.

    It's obvious to anyone who read the thread just closed, that most of L-F members who participated in the discussion…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    The "FP's experiments discussion" has been closed a few hours ago (1). No problem for me. I already had the opportunity to fully illustrate my one point: the errors in the F&P conclusions on their 1992 boil-off experiment.


    I'm sorry for those who were…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread FP's experiments discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from JedRothwell)


    As already happened (1), JR modifies the words in my sentences in order to prove his theses:
    He wrote: "… Fleischmann and dozens of co-workers all know the results were invalid."
    I had instead written: "… F&P had a dozen of
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread FP's experiments discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Alan Smith)


    Misrepresentation and dishonesty are two different concepts. Misrepresentation is an untruthful representation of facts, in our case experimental data, caused by incompetence or inadvertence or intentionality, etc. So it concerns…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread FP's experiments discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from oystla)


    Yes, no doubt the facts you have reported highlight a fascinating story about the mystery of human nature.

    But beware, you are reading the book upside down. :)

    (Quote)


    Exactly! It would have been quite simple to weigh each cell and…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread FP's experiments discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Zeus46)


    Good point. Thanks for having highlighted it.

    You can better understand the 2 phrases of mine, considering that incompetence or inadvertence or intentionality concern the factual level, ie they describe the material cause of the…
  • Ascoli65

    Replied to the thread FP's experiments discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Wyttenbach)


    You really are a strange guy! What I'm doing here is the review of the F&P paper presented at ICCF3, in order to find possible errors in the results of the boil-off experiment reported in it, as asked by Rothwell at the end of…