Bob Member

  • Male
  • from Midwest - United States
  • Member since Jul 23rd 2016
  • Last Activity:
Posts
672
Likes Received
1,747
Points
5,115
Profile Hits
1,372
  • Bob

    Like (Post)
    Heh, so much BS, so little time. The professor in question listed Rossi as someone who demonstrated high energy production from LENR. He said that in a U of Illinois course syllabus. You don't teach frauds as valid science to students. Not at U of I…
  • Bob

    Post
    Magicsound,
    Again thanks for the updates and the experiments in general!

    Any word from Johnny 5? I have not seen any posts here recently.

    Since the early initial run showed an interesting result, do you think you will re-run that phase to see if the…
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Alan Smith)


    It is probably reasonable that there are some instances of "career damage". However, I think this tremendously over blown.
    Does Dr. McKubre think his career greatly damaged because of his links to LENR?
    Does Dr. Duncan think his…
  • Bob

    Post
    (Quote from magicsound)

    Bummer!
    But job well done!
    J5.... any thoughts?
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Alan Smith)

    I agree. Sometimes interpretations of statements can be misread, same as posts about data/events can be misread/misunderstood.
    For the vast majority, I believe most here hold the view that the Androcles is being subjected to…
  • Bob

    Like (Post)
    Maybe I am wrong but I worry that when someone gives Rossi any credit it may cause him to reach for his laywer.


    "Mine, my precious."
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)

    I believe a bit of a misconception is here as well. I really do not know what they are doing, nor do I think that they are necessarily in isolation.
    The only "complaint" I have is that we get mixed signals. Posts that the fossil…
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)

    This is a bit what I am talking about. Even if the Androcles does turn out to be replicable, it really does not shine any positive light on Rossi!
    Other than perhaps Rossi's lies about factories, high COP, direct thrust, direct…
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)


    I certainly hope it is "of sorts"! Anyone who endorses Rossi certainly has questionable judgment in some areas. Areas that hopefully do not cast shadows on current work.

    Simply put, unless someone has direct knowledge of eCats…
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Bruce__H)


    Yes, and this after he claims to have achieved "sigma 5"! Although he never has stated what he supposedly achieved "sigma 5" on or even what it is!
    Most on ECW chimed that it was reliability. Well, if he actually did achieve…
  • Bob

    Post
    (Quote from kirkshanahan)

    Thanks for the input. I hope that with Magicsound's experience, training and abilities.... reasonable input from various sources such as yourself... and some common cooperation that the truth can be found. After all, that is…
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Frstfddl)


    This "strange radiation" anomaly, while interesting, is also a bit problematic. Some of the top researchers, (F&P, McKubre) etc. did not detect this strange radiation to my understanding. This opens the question is this…
  • Bob

    Post
    (Quote from THHuxleynew)

    As often, valid points.
    However, I would like your thoughts on replication versus investigation.

    I do not think the J5 findings have been fully replicated yet. Until that is done and confirmed, then changing parameters would be…
  • Bob

    Post
    (Quote from Bruce__H)

    Can you expand on your reasoning of "no lenr" effect? I would agree that this is a long, long ways from being proof positive for sure. However, 160% increase in unknown radiation counts is hardly a datum for no lenr. I realize…
  • Bob

    Post
    (Quote from Robert Horst)

    These are very valid points to my reasoning. One of the problems with experiments, is that 100 people can come up with 100 "possible" artifacts.
    It is a tough task for sure.

    So one very important method in my book is the…
  • Bob

    Post
    (Quote from magicsound)

    Hey, this is a good start! A replication attempt and the very first run shows promise. As you say, not bullet proof, but that is really ok. At least it provides enough to keep seriously looking into. How many other LENR type…
  • Bob

    Post
    (Quote from Zeus46)

    True indeed!
    A bad phrase on my part. My intent was that most reported classic "LENR" has not reported any radiations. Although, to be honest, I do not know what "classic" LENR would be! ;) There have been a few different forms. …
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Adrian Ashfield)

    Yet you listen to "Rossi says" with faith! LOL.

    As Roseland67 wrote

    (Quote from Roseland67)


    I must agree. You are clueless.
    " that mainly sounds like you were a technician working for a supplier" is a fine example. You…
  • Bob

    Post
    Magicsound,

    Big thumbs up for sharing this work. I wish you the best and success!

    It would be logical that any black or white residue might be due to oxidation, but I do not remember if the cell is open to the atmosphere or not?

    On the outside…
  • Bob

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Director)

    Director,
    This is what pro-Rossi people need to realize and wake up to. (In my opinion) "Rock solid" and "we know...included multiple features" is all wishful thinking! You wish this to be the case, but it is not.

    If…