Sherlock Holmes Student

  • Member since Mar 3rd 2017
  • Last Activity:
Posts
77
Likes Received
58
Points
443
Profile Hits
108
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread Betting for or against LENR.
    Post
    (Quote from maryyugo)


    As you know, Mary, I'm a fervid follower of Rossi, so "In mercatu veritas" is also my motto. I won't pay until I can buy an E-cat .
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    Bockris, Gerischer, or Fleischmann, oy vey! I don't give a flying fig about their opinions, much less yours.


    Again, shmuck, can you show me LENR? 20K on the line. Since SO many people have shown LENR SO many times, someone there must have all the
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from JedRothwell)

    Wait a sec. F&P had been replicated thousands of times, but if I ask someone to do it it will take "You could replicate with the Storms method if you happen to be an expert in electrochemistry and you have a well-equipped lab…
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Papp engine and cavitation.
    Post
    Right. So I suggest you propose to NASA that instead of spending money in unreliable rockets they send people to the moon via a huge cannon. Why not? A genius like Jules Verne proposed it. Another genius, Ptolemy, supported the geocentric paradigm.…
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Papp engine and cavitation.
    Post
    Isn't it a constant with inventions from the Teslas (post insanity) and the Papps of this world that, despite the incredible leaps in technology that we have seen lately, nobody can reproduce them?
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Papp engine and cavitation.
    Post
    Sorry, Axil, I didn't realize you were talking Tom Clancy on a website devoted to LENR.
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Papp engine and cavitation.
    Post
    Only LENR could explain that his home-made submarine could cross the Atlantic at 160MPH on a single charge of fuel. Unless you think that he made up the whole thing.

    Unthinkable, right? You don't think that he was bullshitting the gullible about the…
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread Betting for or against LENR.
    Post
    Mary, I'm afraid I bet on you behalf on another thread, I'm pretty sure you won't mind. If you do, I'll cover you.
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Papp engine and cavitation.
    Post
    Axil, don't you think that the submarine engine is closer to LENR?
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Papp engine and cavitation.
    Post
    Are you talking about his sort-of car engine or about the engine that propelled the submarine he constructed in his garage across the Atlantic at 160 MPH and which sunk right at the spot where he could swim to the shore?
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    OK. F&P's epoch-making experiment was a table-top thing. Definitely low five figures. It has been replicated hundreds of times, right?

    I bet 10K (and I'm sure MY will bet another 10K) that none of those hundreds can replicate it on command. (Sorry…
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Playground.
    Post
    (Quote from Alan Smith)


    Fear of what? F&P got 50 millions from Toyota, Rossi got 10.5 from IH, Pokemov got 20 reactors made by MFMP distributed to replicants who could not replicate, fear of what?

    A black helicopter showering you with 100 dollar…
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Playground.
    Post
    (Quote from IH Fanboy)

    What are you afraid of, Fanboy? Skepticism is not contagious and it's only dangerous to scammers.
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Playground.
    Post
    Alain, the 0.1% chance would still have been there if IH had recruited Mary Yugo to test the E-cat. Remember, 0.00% of a trillion dollars is still 0 dollars.

    I insist: putting as a condition for the 10.5 mil that MY and her team test the E-cat would…
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Playground.
    Post
    Copy/Paste from my post at Revolution-green.com:


    "Simon, I disagree with your assessment. Considering Rossi's long history of legal problems and the fact that the the E-cat has been called a scam for years, DUE DILIGENCE would have included hiring the…
  • (Quote from Adrian Ashfield)


    IF the COP is as high as claimed... How many years now Rossi has been claiming a high COP? How many more years are you going to wait for him to put a product in the market before realizing it's all smoke and mirrors?

  • Sherlock Holmes

    Like (Post)
    (Quote from IH Fanboy)

    This is grossly unfair. In an academic discussion this statement would not be allowed. IHFB is free to assert that we are mistaken, but he goes way over the line when he says we are evil. He should dispute our judgement and not try…
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)


    It's time to institute the Neville Chamberlain Award for Best Ignoring Warning Signals. Some worthy nominees:

    Tom Darden

    Bob Greenyer

    Mats Lewan
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Playground.
    Post
    Once MFMP finishes raising 320K for Suhas, maybe Bob can encourage the E-catworld crowd to contribute here:

    http://www.cnn.com/2015/03/13/…ollar-jet-feat/index.html
  • Sherlock Holmes

    Replied to the thread The Playground.
    Post
    (Quote from LENR Calender)


    Err...no. In the LENR multiverse, a "weird turn" would have been for MFMP to go there and find a working reactor, no if, buts or maybes. But instead of telling Suhas: "Call us back once you have all your ducks in a row."…