JedRothwell Verified User
- Member since Oct 11th 2014
- Last Activity:
- Posts
- 3,337
- Likes Received
- 4,066
- Points
- 20,866
- Profile Hits
- 2,578
-
JedRothwell
Replied to the thread Rossi vs. Darden aftermath discussions.Post(Quote from axil)
Huizenga was correct about the theory, but incorrect when he concluded that it cannot happen, or that it did not happen. The experiments show that it did happen, so his theories are overruled. That's the scientific method. When theory… -
JedRothwell
Replied to the thread Is there evidence for LENR power generation of 100W for days without input power?.Post(Quote from THHuxleynew)
As I mentioned elsewhere, there is a consensus among people who have performed the experiments and people who have read the literature. The majority of the ones who have published papers or talked to me believe that cold fusion… -
JedRothwell
Like (Post)THHuxleynew
You seem perfectly happy to accept Kirk's theories of how the anomalous heat effect in Pd/D can be explained by something other than LENR, despite the fact that AFAIK he has never performed any experiments to test his hypothesis directly,… -
JedRothwell
Liked [email protected] post in the thread Rossi vs. Darden aftermath discussions.Like (Post)(Quote from maryyugo)
-
JedRothwell
Replied to the thread Rossi vs. Darden aftermath discussions.Post(Quote from THHuxleynew)
You are confused. The consensus of experts is that cold fusion is real. I do not know any leading electrochemist who disagrees, and I know lots of leading electcrochemists. Perhaps you have in mind the consensus of plasma… -
JedRothwell
Post(Quote from [email protected])
The depositions by Murray and Smith have additional detail. I read only a small portion of the deposition by Rossi, so I do not know if he addressed this. -
JedRothwell
Like (Post)(Quote from interested observer)
-
JedRothwell
Like (Post)(Quote from maryyugo)
Jed is right, you just keep moving the goal posts. The goal posts were set and met more than 20 years ago when the top hundred or so electrochemists of the day replicated the Pons-Fleischmann Anomalous Heat Effect and submitted… -
JedRothwell
Post(Quote from interested observer)
See:
http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/McKubreMCHcoldfusionb.pdf
See chapter 1, by me and Mallove:
http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/RothwellJcoldfusiona.pdf -
JedRothwell
Liked can’s post in the thread Ed Storms: Ruby Carat Video On The Hydrotron.Like (Post)A partial transcription of the on-screen captions appearing in the video.
(Quote)
-
JedRothwell
Liked can’s post in the thread Ed Storms: Ruby Carat Video On The Hydrotron.Like (Post)I found these excerpts interesting when put together:
(Quote)
Storms' idea of cold fusion/LENR however is limited to cracks forming in a material. What does he think about plasma-based experiments? If the same or similar processes occur in a plasma,… -
JedRothwell
Liked AlainCo’s post in the thread Ed Storms: Ruby Carat Video On The Hydrotron.Like (Post)about plasma experiments, I remember of Russian experiments, who are not pure plasma, but heterogeneous plasmoids with metal powder mixed in a plasma...
Note that many plasma experiments are using electrodes, where there is a metallic surface.
I'm… -
JedRothwell
Post(Quote from damn_right _man)
Many years ago the people at BLP told me they do not think cold fusion exists. Maybe they have a different opinion now? Anyway, AFAIK, they do not accept it and they are not promoting it.
Rossi is certainly not helping the… -
JedRothwell
Like (Post)(Quote from AlainCo)
You can't defend LENR with E-Cat. Connection E-Cat with LENR is only on Rossi not on You. The best is to study Jed's library and using arguments You really understand.
The worst case is to turn on attorneys. Much better is "healthy… -
JedRothwell
Post(Quote from [email protected])
Murray and Smith did this. They did a far better job than I could. So I suggest you read what they wrote.
Penon, Murray and Smith are here:
http://coldfusioncommunity.net…/01/0197.03_Exhibit_3.pdf
… -
JedRothwell
Like (Post)(Quote from maryyugo)
Jed says that the Penon report is what turned his perspective. I keep hoping that he'll publish his own thread with a paragraph by paragraph dismantling of the report. It would appear he has better things to do. -
JedRothwell
Post(Quote from interested observer)
I suggest you address the issue. Why are you expressing strong opinions about a technical subject you know nothing about? You agree that you know nothing, and you are contributing nothing. You just said that!
What are… -
JedRothwell
Post(Quote from THHuxleynew)
It is often difficult to tell them apart. Sometimes both contribute to a fiasco. Or what starts off as incompetence devolves into a cover-up and malfeasance. This happens in science, and in other disasters such as failed business… -
JedRothwell
Like (Post)(Quote from can)
Yes, something like. I have this problem too. ascoli's thesis is (1) the early academic helpers of Rossi (specifically Levi) were deliberately making the tests look good and (2) something more complex.
I leave (2) alone, since it is… -
JedRothwell
Post(Quote from interested observer)
Then why do you make these comments? What is the point? This is a science-oriented forum. If you comments contribute nothing to science, and if -- as you say -- you have not read the papers and you know nothing about the…