Ascoli's useful observations on the 2016 data (that is the 100% excess power 2017 published results that preceded the R19 and R20 results):
- The input power is measured differently between the control and active run spreadsheets. In the control
Has there ever been a spreadsheet posted of the raw data for R20? There are a lot of disagreements that seem to be partly occurring due to a lack of data. If the spreadsheet needs cleaned up a bit, then it seems like that would take a lot less time…
My intuition has been damn good in separating the BS from the Shinola in several past sets of claims. In fact, it has been 100%.
The jury is still out on this one and I have been as neutral, in fact supportive, as possible under the…
(Quote from seven_of_twenty)
I'm looking at this bit by bit, so not claiming any specific issue is known a problem, but nothing it as a posible problem.
In this case PSU effciency can be low (like, 10%). So with calibration input measured before the…
(Quote from Daniel_G)
Daniel, i would agree with you but for two issues:
I) Mizuno has corrected data based on efficiency etc and not documented that. So we'd need to verify whether this was done with the power input, because it would be easy to do it…
(Quote from RobertBryant)
Sure is. But I am not going to replicate a whole bunch of incomplete and conflicting specifications. Besides, I will be in the bush for another 10 days or so, starting tomorrow, possibly with (crappy) internet this time, but I…
(Quote from JedRothwell)
Do you have a chart of this? Best to plot input power on X and apparent excess on Y instead of time on X and input power and excess on Y. You can see the relationship much better with the former method.
(Quote from Alan Smith)
Just to get things going
- Air flow calorimetry is known to be less accurate than water flow calorimetry. Reason for switch is not convincing
- Methodological issues with conflation of calculated and measured quantities, lack of
(Quote from Curbina)
Since his calorimetry shows zero excess after a short initial transient it seems quite accurate? That is, unless these systems have some sustained temperature-dependent LENR reaction as Mizuno observed.
The low (max 10%) transient…
Reflections on hotwiregate and Mizuno-style results
(Quote from Alan Fletcher)
(Quote from RobertBryant)
First, a big thank you to Alan for useful investigation and presenting results without presumption or claim to know whether they apply. Alan is…
Review of Mizuno's Air-Flow Calorimetry.
NOTE 1: I am *NOT* an expert
NOTE 2 : I am ONLY concerned with the fan (blower), not with the internals of the box or the conduction/convection/radiation from the walls of the box
This data is all in a google…
(Quote from Paradigmnoia)
Thanks for picking up on this with ACTUAL measurements.
I've been doing some research on the fan issue ... (I am *NOT* an expert in fluid dynamics!!) .. but I've been tied up with other stuff (like backstage crew for a…
Heat is heat. If the system is sufficiently exothermic to overcome losses, and sufficient heat is returned to the reactor from the cooling system (if there is one), the reactor will run without further electrical heater input. If the returned heat is…
THH: Either reactor could be retested with external checking and calorimetry and the level of assurance in these world-changing and disruptive results would greatly increase. I can't see why Mizuno would be against that?
Jed: Why would he be "against…
IMO, a much more straightforward and simple explanation should start by observing that, during the active and control tests, two different resistors were used to heat the two reactors: the active reactor was heated by an internal resistance heater,…
(Quote from CWatters)
I think JedRothwell mentioned that the problem was that water cooled the reactor wall (presumable locally) too much and 'put out the fire'. That seems possible and would rule out immersion calorimetry which looks temptingly…
I suspect that Edison is rolling over in his grave at being compared to Rossi. And well he should. Edison was a creative genius, whatever his personality and shortcomings. His thousands of inventions and insights and investments changed the course of…
(Quote from Mark U)
Mark was it not a sudden change to abandon the "industrialization" of the e-cat SK, with it's 8 out of 10 customer satisfaction scores and robotic manufacturing lines? That seemed sudden to me.
LOL...be aware of another not-so-much-gifted-person-one-man-show-streams-from-his-condo-puppet-show with dancing ballerinas...spot on!
Maybe this time not even with Frank Acland onsite?
- Bernie Morrissey
July 30, 2019 at 9:00 AM
Dear Andrea Rossi,
- Bernie Morrissey July 30, 2019 at 9:00 AM Dear Andrea Rossi,