Roger Student

  • Member since Dec 16th 2016
  • Last Activity:
Posts
153
Likes Received
127
Points
887
Profile Hits
448
  • Roger

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from Debarium)


    We're not, in LENR, dealing as much with science, as with a stale, rancid and angry academia, and with a market whose freedom is abhorrent for some entrenched interests.

    Don't expect shills to be able to engage in rational…
  • Roger

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)


    and yet here you are, repeating this kind of line every couple weeks
    Olol why are people still interested in Rossi

    But hey you're the most friendly of the 3k+ posts shills here, your colleagues are more like
    Olol why are people still
  • Roger

    Like (Post)
    (Quote from Epimetheus)


    i have - because of my own inability to fully grasp the mathematics (or, more, in recognition of the fact that it would take a decade that i don't have to get up-to-speed) - decided to take a different approach.

    rather than try…
  • Roger

    Like (Post)
    (Quote from Eric Walker)


    the test - if i am reading you correctly - is to read the work and follow the derivations, from scratch, and look, for yourself (or trust someone else) if there are any "magic constants" or anything *other* than the (one)…
  • Roger

    Like (Post)
    (Quote from Rical)


    the 27 "constants" of quantum theory are called "postulates". they're basically "total guesses" or more accurately, "Numbers With Zero Explanation That Happen To Make It All Work And We Are Really Really Hoping Nobody Will Notice Or…
  • Roger

    Replied to the thread Ecat producing antimatter??.
    Post
    (Quote from lenrisnotreal)


    Anything is possible my friend. I mean, we live in a world where people spend hours, each and every day, on obscure internet forums, repeating that stuff they're sure is woowoo, is definitely woowoo. It's as if they're trying…
  • (Quote from Shane D.)


    Or maybe you because you are trying to stop it.


    You tell me what is worse at the end of the day; some false hope (hardly noticeable compared to the normal news flow from the same papers) among generally privileged people or the…
  • (Quote from Shane D.)


    You're so right. We absolutely do not want to have any hope. Do we?

    And, the reporter was there, which gives his assessment of Rossi and the situation way more credibility than random rants you make...
  • So that's what happened with the Orbo Cube
    It didn't feel like an outright scam, and this explanation makes sense
  • EOqLkBZm.jpgI also have my own explanation, why Orbo Cube failed, despite some devices generated voltage long time after they were withdrawn from customers. McCarthy feared the lost of IP, so that he casted his circuits into an epoxy resin without further testing,…
  • Roger

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)


    I'm sorry but that doesn't address what you wrote before: "most of the planet knows there will never be a product at all, for obvious reasons."
    What would those obvious reasons be?
  • Roger

    Replied to the thread Rossi-Blog Comment Discussion.
    Post
    (Quote from Shane D.)


    What would those reasons be?
  • (Quote from Shane D.)


    Failing to condemn is not condemning to failure. And who says 'convinced' is a requirement for reporting on anything other than a dishwash detergergent ad? I have said Rossi is a flake as usual, that the demo would/could never…
  • Bob - Well, sorry you feel that way. I have done my best, but in the face of a flood of other reports (Mats, ECW's rep) it seemed unreasonable to write up much of the same things again. I do remain gently skeptical but in general I am positive…
  • Roger

    Liked Tony’s post in the thread Clearance Items.
    Like (Post)
    (Quote from Cydonia)


    This is unfair. Eric is not incompetent at all. He knows exactly what he is doing. You only need to figure out what his priorities are, then all the pieces fits together.
  • Roger

    Like (Post)
    (Quote from THHuxleynew)


    There is one good point in the paper THH referenced. The method used is 6-dimensional, what is needed for nuclear energies.


    The remainder only proves that QM has absolutely no clue about the underlying physics. The authors do…
  • Roger

    Replied to the thread Clearance Items.
    Post
    (Quote from Zeus46)


    I'm not sure being coders or software analysts qualifies as strong technical background in the LENR field. Neither does being electrical engineers (though it's a bit more helpful)
  • (Quote from Eric Walker)


    It could certainly be intentionally "flawed". At least we can be sure not all information was revealed. The reason for this could be argued from any direction I suppose. So I don't understand you point here otherwise than…
  • Come on skeptics. Answer the question or don't you dabble in logic?

    What can Rossi possibly gain by demonstrating a reactor that doesn't work when it would be simple (as the skeptics themselves claim) for any investor to check if it worked?

    Forget…
  • (Quote from Tony)

    Rossi is not the only developer of the LENR tech. There are others who have provided evidence of the activity of the reaction. The question that is not answered with certainty is if Rossi has a viable LENR product or will have a viable…