THHuxleynew Professional

(Quote from [email protected])


I'm not doing that. Please read what I said above more carefully?

(Quote from [email protected])


I posted a significant argument: Rossi vs. Darden aftermath discussions and on other posts in this thread.

(last page of this thread). Perhaps you are not reading very clearly.

More seriously you are twisting what I…

(Quote from SSC)


SSC. I suggest that here you are projecting your thinking onto me.

Thus, there is no logical connection between hopes (what you would like to happen) and expectation (what you think likely to happen). I may hope to win a lottery first…

(Quote from [email protected])


[email protected]

I'm not hiding behind anything, and personalising the issue - attacking the character of opponents - does not advance your argument.

You have repeated the same mantra: the top hundred…

I envy you the solar eclipse Alan. One big advantage of living on a very large national land mass. Good luck! I think this time there will be a larger popular following than previously but with luck the track length will allow it to spread out...

I dislike the dialog being put into characterizations of belief. But this aspect of not accepting perfectly good scientific data until it is commercialized is another threshold to consider about skeptopaths

[email protected]

Have you ever done a…

(Quote from JedRothwell)


Jed: you make my point. I do not have 30 X a couple of months. Indeed I do not have a couple of months full-time work.

It is an inherent problem. Do I trust your views on these papers? No on general principles, I would not…

(Quote from can)


Yes, something like. I have this problem too. ascoli's thesis is (1) the early academic helpers of Rossi (specifically Levi) were deliberately making the tests look good and (2) something more complex.

I leave (2) alone, since it is…

(Quote from Alan Smith)


I don't know whether any poster here is Levi - there are candidates, but possibly none are. Several including rb0 have exhibited identical inability to understand IR thermography or be educated it it to Levi. But that in no way…

(Quote from JedRothwell)


Marwan et al's response was incomplete and partly wrong for the reasons documented in Shanahan's white paper - at least 70% of which I agree with. Perhaps you'd like to go through his critique and say in detail why it is wrong,…

(Quote from Alan Smith)


Well I have no strong hopes from the Swedish guys. it would be fun, but a bit sad, if they continue to use the (not admitted wrong by Levi or any possible Levi poster here) wrong IR thermography that would as P points out easily…

(Quote from Alan Smith)


Good news in this case is at best an interpretation.

(Quote from JedRothwell)


Jed: you are making assumptions about my motives here. I'm not willing to use results I have not looked at and checked all details of - since these matter. I'm assuming that the results McKubre highlights are the most…

"I can't form a conclusion" would automatically nullify whatever he next says.
As I said, that would be like the politician's get-of-jail-card: "I am not a scientist, but . . ." Hey Senator, if you are not a scientist then please shut up. Also, we see…

Gosh Kev, pretty much everything you say to me is in the form of a straw man argument. I make the statement that I can't really form a conclusion about LENR and you insist that I have formed one. You keep yakking about the holy numbers of 100 top…

Just my POV on this useful (though at times repetitive) debate.

Eric's openness to state and justify moderation principles is welcomed by me because I am in favour of transparency. There are reasons for secrecy - but fear of confrontation is IMHO never…

Zephir_AWT : this is a warning. Please do not import tendentious characterizations of religion into this discussion. You did it a few posts back, and I was hoping that would be the last time, but you've done it again. Religion is one of several…

Shane, you had the patience to read all of those files in the Rossi v. Darden docket, and you are pretty detail oriented. I encourage you to read through all of those PDFs on that page you pointed me to when you have the time. I would like to compare…

keV : Sorry but I don't understand your post at all. My posting of the fallacious syllogism was to point out there is no logical connection with the history of the Wright brothers and Rossi or LENR. Yes, popular opinion can be totally wrong about a…

(Quote from [email protected])


Continuing the conversation about your IMHO profound confusion about worth: you are here showing that you don't judge things by content, but instead by whether you think they are relevant. I disagree with your judgement…