I don't think anyone here (well almost) is being dishonest.
I think we all have our opinions and what we want is definitive proof, whether Rossi will ever provide that is unlikely IMHO.
Sadly as the emotion grows and the claims become more shrill the civility and respect decreases.
Glass half full or glass half empty.
This is my take on reading through the various postings.
Theory 1:- Rossi is a fraud.
The evidence is clear in his dishonesty and evasiveness.
His trials and demonstrations are sloppy and flawed to hide his trickery.
Finally, after many years of promising he has repeatedly failed to produce a marketable device.
This is the conclusion from looking back at the evidence.
Theory 2:- Rossi is the real deal.
His dishonesty was forced upon him by dishonest partners, he is not evasive he is necessarily secretive.
His trials and demonstrations may be sloppy and flawed according to scientific standards but Rossi is not a scientist, he is an engineer.
Sure Rossi may have character flaws but In any case none of this is of any import.
The proof will be when he produces the device to market as he has promised.
From this perspective looking back proves nothing and serves no purpose.
Rossi could not possibly be putting all these years of effort in if he did not have what we all hope for. So we must look forward to the promised demonstation. That will settle everything.
And if not this one then maybe the next.