Delta Variant Far Less Deadly than Previous Variants, According to TrialSite Analysis
TrialSite can confirm that the Delta variant is far less deadly than previous versions of SARS-CoV-2 based on an original analysis of the data from The New York Times and Our World in Data. TrialSite assumes that most cases now occurring during this latest pandemic surge are due to the Delta variant.
It would appear that the transmissibility of the Delta variant is severe, and hospitalization is worsening in mostly southern states. We argue that the situation is still unfolding, so our assumptions and perspective may change if we see new data trends that contradict today’s evaluation. While breakthrough infections appear on the rise, the CDC doesn’t track such infections if they do not involve hospitalization. This is a mistake as many vaccinated people are at home quite ill.
Herein, we exhibit that the previous SARS-CoV-2 surges were far more deadly because the media doesn’t seem to touch on this subject. To demonstrate this, we go back to the previous pandemic surges: first from April 1, 2020, to August 1, 2020, and a bigger surge that occurred starting December 1, 2020, to early March 2021.
We list the number of daily new cases based on a 7-day average and the reported number of daily deaths based on the same 7-day average. The first major wave of the pandemic occurred from April 1, 2020, to August 15, 2020. During this surge, while the number of new daily cases was lower than in subsequent surges, the death rates were far higher with the wild-type SARS-CoV-2. What follows is a breakdown of the numbers for the TrialSite reader.
First Pandemic Surge
Date New Cases (7-day avg) Deaths Mortality Ratio %
April 1, 2020 20,974 610 2.91%
April 15, 2020 29,993 2,196 7.32%
May 1, 2020 28,553 1,935 6.78%
May 15, 2020 22,779 1,446 6.35%
June 1, 2020 21,518 989 4.60%
June 15, 2020 22,133 725 3.28%
July 1, 2020 43,767 881 2.01%
July 15, 2020 63,165 727 1.15%
Aug 1, 2020 62,594 1,229 1.96%
During the first pandemic’s surge, the mortality ratio (as defined by new daily cases and daily deaths ratio based on 7-day averages) clearly shows what many already know—because the novel coronavirus was new, there were no treatments and the risk profiles were not well understood yet—by far, the deadliest variant was that original wild-type variant from Wuhan, China.
What became clear during the first surge is that although there were far fewer cases, the mortality ratio was extremely high, spiking up to 7.32% by April 15. The mean mortality rate for this particular surge was a significantly high 4.04%.
Again, there are several elements behind this. SARS-CoV-2 was brand new, and health systems and hospitals didn’t know how to treat it. Moreover, some of the breakthroughs that came later on, such as the dexamethasone findings from the RECOVERY trial, helped reduce subsequent death rates. Although medical authorities in the United States and Europe don’t accept select repurposed and generic early-stage COVID-19 treatments, substantial real-world data indicates drugs like ivermectin may have helped to mitigate the pandemic’s severity in places like India and Mexico. These treatments are also in use off-label in the United States. But suffice to say, SARS-CoV-2 was significantly more deadly during this first pandemic surge.
The Second Pandemic Surge
Date New Cases (7-day avg) Deaths Mortality Ratio %
Oct 1, 2020 43,444 712 1.64%
Oct 15, 2020 54,715 701 1.28%
Nov 1, 2020 82,835 825 1.00%
Nov 15, 2020 150,349 1,148 0.76%
Dec 1, 2020 161,263 1,542 0.96%
Dec 15, 2020 217,320 2,481 1.14%
Jan 1, 2021 195,173 2,513 1.29%
Jan 15, 2021 232,172 3,307 1.42%
Feb 1, 2021 146,664 3,160 2.15%
Feb 15, 2021 85,762 3,030 3.53%
March 1, 2021 67,512 2,043 3.03%
March 15, 2021 55,051 1,397 2.54%
April 1, 2021 65,402 893 1.37%
The number of cases in the second surge far exceeded the first surge, ranging from October 1, 2020, to April 1, 2021. Moreover, the total volume of death was far higher. But was the mortality ratio higher? We could expect it to be lower as several breakthroughs occurred throughout the world, improving techniques in keeping people alive. These include various clinical trial findings, the authorization of remdesivir, and the considerable use of the off-label treatments ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine as well as others. Moreover, a couple of companies had their monoclonal antibody treatments authorized on an emergency use basis, contributing to better urgent COVID-19 care. The mean mortality ratio for this second surge was 1.70%, far lower than what was experienced during the first surge at 4.04%. Vaccines rolled out at the end of 2020 and would have started to have some impact by the end of quarter 1 2021.
Now fast forward to the most recent stretch of the pandemic, driven by the Delta variant of interest.
Delta Variant Surge
Wave of Pandemic New Cases (7-day avg) Deaths Mortality Ratio %
July 1, 2021 19,722 256 1.30%
July 15, 2021 28,488 280 0.98%
Aug 1, 2021 79,763 362 0.45%
Aug 9, 2021 124,470 553 0.44%
The Delta-driven surge grew after the 4th of July, which was predictable given the huge crowds congregating during that holiday. And while the mainstream media and the government’s official line is that this surge is a pandemic of the unvaccinated, substantial numbers of vaccinated individuals experienced breakthrough infections (the CDC doesn’t count these cases in hospitals). TrialSite has demonstrated how some of the world’s most vaccinated places are having major Delta-driven surges—clearly, this isn’t just a pandemic of the unvaccinated.
Notably, more treatments are now in place, and about 50% of the country has been fully vaccinated. Consequently, the average mortality ratio during the Delta surge is 0.79%, which is far lower than the previous averages. Below we break down the mortality rates for each surge of the pandemic.
Mortality Ratios During Pandemic
Date Median Mortality Ratio
April – Aug 2020 4.04%
Oct 1, 2020 – April 1, 2020 1.70%
July 1, 2021 – Aug 9, 2021 0.79%
What is clear is that the mortality ratio of the first surge was over five times as high as the most recent Delta-driven surge of the pandemic. Moreover, the first deadliest period was nearly 2.2 times as fatal as the second surge, with the largest number of deaths, at least according to this metric.
Of course, a confluence of factors and forces affect this ratio, including vaccination and various treatment approaches. And while the Delta variant appears more transmissible, according to this ratio, it is far less deadly than past variants, including the wild-type variant from Wuhan, China.
Now, this isn’t to trivialize the current situation. Some states, particularly Texas and Florida, face dangerous pressure now on ICU capacity. This analysis is meant to put the entire evolving situation in perspective. The mainstream media isn’t reporting on these numbers nor is the current POTUS administration
Note the source for this analysis was the New York Times and Our World in Data.