THE WHO'S WHO OF COLD FUSION 2019 thread
Question is: should Rossi be listed on the "Who's Who" list of LENR players? Some feel he should. Others like myself think it best he be left off.
That is my opinion, although I am open to other ideas. Interested in what the Rossi friend, and foe alike think? For this one topic we will suspend kevmo's "Don't start nothing/won't be nothing" policy. You can let loose, but no strong profanity.
Ah, let Rossi have his prime spot on the "Who's Who in LENR/CF” list!
After all, still a lot of LENR-ist consider that his e-cats have merit - just see who all attended the Stockolm Stockholm presentation.
As long as his claims get the attention from the LENR community, he reflects somehow the spirit of (part of) this community, and his influence can’t be ignored.
How would one justify that Parkhomov is on the list, but not Rossi?
And in case you mark Rossi as “controversial”, then you should check who else on that list should be called “controversiall (Just google the individual names together with the word “controversial”)
Anyhow, you better mark also in the list what claims are just “hearsay” or rumours, and what is based on evidence.
E.g From where does the info come, that Siemens is working (“silently”) on LENR?
(I also read somewhere else the rumour that some escaped NAZI use LENR reactor at their hideout on the south-pole - or was it on the backside of the moon?)
There is also no “Seashore” listed in the “Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation” database of grantees.
And why is the deceased Sven Kullander on that list, but not Martin Fleischmann?
And why Ruby Karat, Steven Krivit, but no Jed Rothwell (and no Frank Acland)?
And finally, why is the UK laboratory (that former milk barn, where the lovely gammas dance now) on the list, but not the Czech “wine cellar” lab (where the Quark-X style reactor was glowing)?
I know, it became a bit quite about me356 now, and one difference is that me356 is anonymous for most of us, but not for all (e.g. not for Bob G. and other MFMP guys).