On the contrary, everyone I know (other than Rossi and Penon) who was involved in the Doral test said there was no excess heat. They sent me sample data and based on that, I agreed.
Have you read the reports from Penon, Murray and Smith? If you have, and you still think there was excess power from any part of that reactor, then you and I have vastly different technical standards and I do not think we can ever agree about anything.
The most damning evidence against the Doral test was the Penon report, which was uploaded by Rossi himself. It was on the basis of this report, and nothing else, that he demanded $267 million. Do you think he deserved the $267 million? Did you find that report convincing?
I misspoke. I meant that no[one] at the Doral site complained that the small E-Cats were failing to produce excess power. They were humming away for just over 2 weeks from Feb 1 to Feb 17 and no one on site complained that they were failing in any way. Not Rossi, not Fabiani, not Penon. So if SSC is now coming along saying that Rossi took them out of service because he was able to see that they had ineffective loads in them then I am asking for more evidence on that point. I think that the small E-Cats looked just like the Big Frankies to Rossi because all that site ever contained was passive resistors.
* square brackets show my later edit
Moved from the pump thread. Alan.